Will Pudding Set Using Almond Milk?

Only JELL-O Instant Puddings should be used with the directions below. JELL-O Cook & Serve pudding is not compatible with these instructions. See the following section for our JELL-O Cook & Serve instructions. Keep the following tips in mind while creating quick pudding with almond milk or other plant-based milks:

  • When compared to pudding made with dairy milk, pudding made with almond milk or other plant-based milks will have a distinct set, mouthfeel, and flavor.
  • The texture of the set will be soft to extremely soft, with a spoonable consistencyit will not be as soft as JELL-O Pudding produced with milk.
  • We recommend soy, almond, and coconut milks as milk substitutes based on the results of our culinary experts’ tests. Most other plant-based milks prevent the pudding from setting.
  • In place of 2 cups of milk, use 1-1/2 cups of soy, almond, or coconut milk in quick pudding.
  • It’s only ideal for spoonable desserts like trifles, parfaits, and other sweets with a similar texture if used in a dessert recipe.
  • Desserts that require a solid firmness, such as pudding pies, eclair cakes, or striped delight, will not work with plant-based milks (square layered desserts). Plant-based milks are not recommended for these types of sweets.

How do you thicken almond milk pudding?

So there you have it: making pudding with almond milk is doable!


  • If the pudding is too thick, add a spoonful of almond milk at a time until it reaches your desired consistency.

When cooking pudding, can almond milk be used instead of milk?

Pudding is an excellent place to start if you want to incorporate more plant-based milks into your cooking and baking. Despite the fact that many pudding recipes call for dairy milk, did you know that you can create pudding with almond milk or other plant-based milks? You can use oat milk, soy milk, almond milk, and other plant-based milk instead of dairy milk in JELL-O Puddings. It’s not a 1:1 ratio, so keep reading to learn how to prepare plant-based pudding using JELL-O Instant Pudding and JELL-O Cook & Serve Pudding with a range of plant-based milks.

Is it possible to make pudding with almond milk?

In a medium saucepan, combine the Cook & Serve pudding mix with 2 cups of refrigerated unsweetened almond milk to make Jell-O pudding with almond milk. On medium heat, bring to a boil, stirring continually. Remove from heat and let aside for at least 5 minutes to cool. We discovered that mixing the pudding inside that 5-minute timeframe made it lumpy, so it’s crucial to wait the full 5 minutes. Warm or cooled is fine.

In a pudding, what may I use instead of milk?

Pudding mixes are convenient and delicious sweets, but what if you don’t have any milk?

I’ve been asked several times if it’s possible to create pudding mix without milk, and the answer is yes!

When cooking pudding, you can use a variety of substitutes for milk. Some work better than others, but you can definitely make your pudding without milk if you use all of the choices I’ll show you.

Coconut milk, almond milk, cashew milk, soy milk, oat milk, powdered milk, whipping cream, and cocoa powder are the best milk substitutes in pudding mix.

What is the best way to thicken a Jello pudding that won’t set?

If you don’t have cornstarch on hand, you can thicken with other starches like tapioca. Make sure to heat the starch to the point of gelatinization, which varies depending on the type of starch. Because the thickening strength of different starches varies, you may need to use more of one than the other to achieve the same thickening results.

For instance, arrowroot flour is a gluten-free starch that gelatinizes at lower temperatures than most other starches, making it an excellent choice for making homemade pudding with eggs. Because you don’t want to overheat the eggs to the point where they coagulate, you may merely heat the mixture slightly and the arrowroot will thicken it up.

However, when arrowroot is combined with dairy, it has peculiar qualities that can result in an unpleasant sliminess, thus it may not be the ideal choice for pudding for that reason, though it has been found to work well in pudding for others.

To thicken overly thin instant pudding, simply add another package or a portion of a packet of instant pudding mix. This will raise the starch and thickening agent to liquid ratio, thickening it to the desired consistency.

Is it possible to create fast Jello pudding using almond milk?

Make JELL-O pudding with almond milk instead of regular milk. JELL-O Pudding with Non-Dairy Milk is delicious on its own, as well as in trifles and parfaits. In a medium mixing bowl, whisk together the pudding mix and 1 cup milk for 2 minutes. (Be prepared for a thick pudding.)

What is the best way to thicken instant pudding?

Especially if you’re gluten-free, cornstarch is likely something you already have in your pantry. It’s most well-known for its thickening properties, and it’s also flavorless. You don’t want to put powder cornstarch in your instant pudding mix, though! Because cornstarch thickens with heat, you’ll need to produce a slurry first. It also aids in preventing clumping.

  • Heat the instant pudding and gradually whisk in the slurry mixture over low heat until you achieve the desired consistency (the pudding mix will need to be almost boiling for this to work)

It’s crucial to remember that the mixture will thicken as it cools, so make it a little thinner than you want it to be to give it time to thicken up.

What is the best way to thicken almond milk?

This dish does necessitate the use of some unusual kitchen utensils. You’ll need a blender and a large pot, both of which you probably already have, as well as a fine mesh filter bag to drain the blended almond pulp from the finished milk. You can buy these reusable nut milk bags online for approximately $7-15 apiece (see Amazon here), or you can buy paint filter bags for about $1 each at your local hardware shop. I’m not sure if they’re “food grade,” but I wash mine in hot soapy water several times before using them and they’re fine.

Step One

Soak the almonds for at least 6 hours, preferably 10-12 hours. The almonds soften and absorb a lot of the water as they soak. When mixed, this causes them to break down more quickly and contribute more flavor to the milk.

Step Two

Drain and rinse the almonds after they have been properly soaked. Then combine them with water and salt in a big mixer (a Vitamix can handle the full batch, but you may have to do 2 batches with a smaller blender). To properly break down the almonds, blend for at least 2-3 minutes. Allow this to “steep” (much like tea) for 5-10 minutes to get the greatest flavor.

Step Three

Strain the mixture through your handy milk straining bag (or paint filter bag) and into a big pitcher below. Slowly press the nut pulp with your hands to get all of the juice. This procedure parallels the act of milking a cow (which is ironic), but let’s not go there… After straining all of the milk, you’ll be left with a lump of almond pulp. You can throw this away, use it to make pates, or dehydrate it and use it as almond flour.

Taste the milk and add any more flavorings if desired. I frequently add a dash of vanilla and maple syrup to my coffee.

Step Four

Now it’s time to have some fun! In my several trials with this procedure, I’ve discovered that at the correct temperature, the thickening reaction occurs quickly and produces a liquid that is extremely thick when chilled (more viscous than heavy cream). Depending on your needs, this may be overly thick and inconvenient. The easiest technique to control the viscosity is to keep some almond milk unthickened while heating and thickening the rest, then combining the two for the optimal whole milk consistency.

To do so, set aside half of the thin almond milk in a pitcher and pour the remaining half into a big skillet. Increase the heat and whisk regularly until the almond milk reaches a high temperature – we’re practically “scalding” it. When you run a spoon through the hot liquid just before it comes to a boil, you’ll see that it changes from watery to slightly creamy very instantly. That’s exactly what we’re hoping for a reaction. Remove the pan from the heat before it boils and pour the remaining milk into the pitcher, allowing the entire concoction to chill in the refrigerator before serving. And there you have it: thick almond milk!

Can almond milk be substituted for milk?

Use the same amount of unsweetened almond milk that the recipe calls for when substituting almond milk for regular milk. (Some almond milk brands contain added sugar or other sweeteners, which may alter the flavor of your dish.) Add a squeeze of lemon or a splash of vinegar to make buttermilk, which is tangier than milk. Although the almond milk will not be as thick as buttermilk, the acid will help to imitate the flavor.